Don’t Be a ‘Joystick’ Soccer Coach

By Alex Kos

I first heard the term “Joystick Coaching” a few years back. What a wonderfully descriptive term. As with video games, joystick coaches want to dictate and control the movement of all their soccer players on the field. Hence the term “joystick” soccer coaching.

However, there is very little joy to be had by soccer players when they are coached in this manner. Kids don’t do well when they’re being coached by a joystick soccer coach. They might even start to tune out all the noise and just try to have fun – which is what they should do when dealing with a joystick soccer coach.

Joystick soccer coaching has reached epidemic proportions on many a soccer field across the country (and parents are just as guilty). Why is this happening in youth soccer these days?

  • Look at other popular youth sports such as football, baseball and basketball. Football and baseball coaches are joystick experts. Even in basketball where the game is more fluid (like soccer) and, therefore, more difficult to control and manipulate, coaches still try their best to dictate the action. Since many soccer coaches come from these backgrounds, it is only natural that joystick coaching carries over into soccer.
  • We are a sports nation hung up on X’s and O’s. Joy sticking is a natural by-product of this fascination. How many times do you see defenders standing in one spot because that is where the defenders were positioned on the dry-erase board by the “coach”?
  • Soccer is not an easy sport to learn. No matter how many times coaches tell young players to spread out and not play bunch-ball, they still do. As such, soccer coaches feel compelled to ‘help’ position and move their players about.

Besides early soccer player retirements (everyone has played soccer in their younger days but many move on to other sports) there are other consequences of this “helping” behavior.

  • In a sport that is very fluid where the action happens so quickly, players must be able to think on their feet and solve or address problems immediately. However, the more soccer players are told what to do, the less they will be able to think for themselves.
  • Young soccer players lose their sense of purpose. They are out there to play a game and try their best yet are constantly being told how to play the game. On the streets is where many greats of the game of soccer started to learn how to play, without coaches around.
  • Once one adult starts maneuvering soccer players on the field, other adults feel empowered to do the same. Soon, players are being told how to play and where to stand by coaches, parents, and complete strangers. And often, the three groups are giving three completely different instructions. What is a young player to do?

These are some simple tips that will help soccer coaches curb the joystick soccer coaching epidemic and truly help players.

  • Lead by example. Limited joystick coaching during games as much as possible. It’s fine to coach during soccer practice, that’s what you’re there for, but during games, let the players try new things and learn on their own.
  • Set ground rules for your assistant coaches and parents. Explain the drawback of joystick soccer coaching and having multiple adults “help” players with conflicting instructions.
  • Rather than telling players what to do and where to play, ask them how and where they should be playing. Let them think of the answer and assist only if they don’t know the answer. Get your players to help one and another too, let them work as a team to solve problems on the field.

Soccer coaches (and parents), leave your joysticks hooked up to your game consoles at home for use with FIFA 10. Yes, there are a ton of adults out there who play video games. If you don’t, you’ll be using the actual joystick much more since Saturday mornings will soon be free.

Soccer is a creative game and kids should be allowed to express themselves on the pitch, not always told how they should play.

(Alex Kos’ experiences as a player, coach, referee, parent and fan are shared in his blog, Improving Soccer in the United States, where this article first appeared.)

Soccer coaches learn more at this pages below: