An independent commission has found Manchester City guilty of breaching the Premier League’s financial rules across nine seasons, and the club has already lodged an appeal. As of early October 2026, no punishment has been decided: a separate sanctions hearing and a new appeal panel will shape what happens next.
What Was Manchester City Charged With?
The Premier League first announced the charges in February 2023, following an investigation that began in 2018. Known as the “115 charges” case, it covered alleged breaches of financial reporting rules between the 2009-10 and 2017-18 seasons, and alleged failures to cooperate with the league’s investigation in the years that followed.
An independent commission heard the case in private over 42 days in 2024, according to law firm Mishcon de Reya.
What Did the Independent Commission Decide?
On September 29, 2026, the Premier League published the commission’s decision. According to the Premier League’s statement, the commission found City guilty of:
- All of the charges relating to financial rule breaches across the nine seasons from 2009-10 to 2017-18.
- Three of the four alleged categories of failing to cooperate with the league’s investigation. The fourth was not proven.
The commission found that City had arranged what it described as “sham” commercial contracts with sponsors and filed misstated accounts, overstating revenues and understating costs by more than 900 million pounds. In the published decision, the commission said: “By its conduct the club clearly intended to circumvent the PL Rules.” Premier League chief executive Richard Masters said: “This disciplinary case, and this decision, are the most significant in Premier League history.”
How Has Manchester City Responded?
City rejects the findings. In a club statement on the day of publication, the club said it was “both disappointed and surprised” and that it “is innocent of the accusations made by the Premier League.” The club said the decision “contains clear material errors, of law, principle and fact, and is unsafe.”
City then lodged what it called a “comprehensive” appeal at 7pm on Thursday, October 1, one day before the Friday deadline. Chief executive Ferran Soriano has said the case rests on what he called “a single false accusation” about owner funding through Abu Dhabi sponsors, as reported by Al Jazeera.
The Football Association also commented, saying the decision “has significant implications for the integrity of the game” and that it will “take action where appropriate.”
What Comes Next: The Confirmed Steps
1. The appeal
Under the Premier League’s rules, the appeal is heard by a new three-person panel, not the commission that made the original decision, according to Sky Sports. AP reporting, carried by several outlets, says the rules call for the appeal hearing to take place within 12 weeks of the appeal being filed. No hearing date had been made public as of early October 2026.
2. The sanctions hearing
The decision does not set a punishment. Sanctions will be considered at a separate private hearing before the commission. The Premier League’s rules allow a range of outcomes, including a reprimand, a fine, a suspension, a points deduction or expulsion. Sky Sports notes there is no fixed tariff for financial breaches. It was not clear, as of early October, whether any sanction could take effect before the appeal is decided.
What Is Still Speculation?
These points are not confirmed:
- The size of any points deduction. Pundits have floated figures, but nothing has been proposed publicly or decided.
- Titles being stripped or relegation. Raised by commentators, not decided.
- Further legal action. Reports suggest City could challenge the process in England’s High Court (the Court of Arbitration for Sport is not available for this case) and that rival clubs could explore compensation claims.
On the field, as of early October 2026, City lead the Premier League heading into their October 11 game against Liverpool.
What Young Players and Families Can Learn
For academy players and parents, the lesson is about how clubs operate. Squad building is shaped by budgets, rules and long-term planning, not just talent, and financial rules affect how much room clubs have to sign players versus promote from within. For the business side, see our piece on what it costs to start an MLS team, and our guide to how U.S. youth soccer leagues operate.
What to watch for as a family:
- Ask any academy how players move up: what share of first-team or top-group minutes go to homegrown players?
- Focus on what you control. Clubs change; your ball mastery, decision-making and 1v1 confidence travel with you wherever you go.
- Coaches: run a simple “squad-building” session. Give your team a fixed number of “player credits” and ask them to design a 7v7 lineup for a small-sided game based on roles, not star names. It teaches that balance beats collecting talent, an idea at the heart of Barcelona’s La Masia.
Frequently Asked Questions
Has Manchester City been punished yet?
No. As of early October 2026, sanctions are still to be decided at a separate private hearing.
Has Manchester City appealed?
Yes. City lodged an appeal on October 1, 2026, saying the decision contains material errors of law, principle and fact. A new three-person panel will hear it.
Could City be relegated or lose titles?
The rules allow sanctions up to expulsion, but no specific penalty has been proposed or decided. Talk of relegation or stripped titles is speculation at this stage.
Coach it with your own team.
The Coerver Session Planner gives youth coaches ready-made practice sessions built on the Coerver method: fun, organized and packed with touches on the ball.